Devor and how I really am not as much of a unique snowflake as I had hoped
I found the Lorber Devor reading to be both insightful and informative. While I was reading, I could not help but apply Lorber’s Devor's points to my “I.” Imagine my delight when I found out that the first blog prompt synced up with what I was already doing. :)
The first time that I actively considered the implications gender was when I got yelled at for shouting across the hall of my dorm that “my computer was being gay.” I had never stopped and thought about how or why that term carried negative connotations and why it was so freely used dergoatorily. Maybe it was because of that rude awakening, or the intriguing class title, or possibly because I wanted to take a class with my girlfriend at that time, that lead me to take “History of Sexuality.”
Before taking “History of Sexuality,” I had blindly conformed to conventional gender roles. However, the socializations/expectations of these roles that I “followed” were Western based. I make this distinction because in Saudi Arabia, it is customary for male friends, to kiss on the cheeks when greeting each other and that it was not unusual to witness these men hold hands as they walked. Personally, I perceived it as “weird.”
I was/am not homophobic. I was just apathetic, which arguably could be just as worse. It was not “weird” in an uncomfortable sense to witness these exchanges between two males; it was just a different culture from the one that I had been accustomed. As a Filipino, despite being heavily influenced by Western culture, we still tolerate, if not accept, homosexuals in our society. On a side note, I briefly looked up homosexuality in the Philippines and what I discovered was that the word “kasarian” which resembles “gender” in English, does not imply a dichotomy like its English counterpart. Instead, it simply means “kind, species, or genus” according to the Tagalog-English Dictionary. 2nd. ed. 1986. Also, it is interesting to note that the origin of the English word “gender” did not imply a gender binary as it originally meant “kind.” (dictionary.com)
“To what extent have you been pressured to conform to conventional roles?” What a tough question. Tough, not because it’s difficult to find the answer, but tough because it is difficult TO answer. I would like to say that I have not been pressured to conform in any way shape or form but deep down I know that I am largely a product of society. (What a terrible thing to admit, I guess I’m not exactly a special little snowflake :P.) I am sure that during my early childhood, before I consciously began to examine who “I” was, everybody was a “generalized other;” the only “significant others” would have to be my parents or babysitter as I am sure they were the only ones that I interacted with enough to be able to establish any association. During my “tween/teenage” years, my parents became less of significant others and the “generalized others” ironically transformed into the “significant others.”
On the flip side, it is easy for me to state that I have not resisted any pressures to conform to conventional roles because I always assumed that gender was inherent/natural. Now that I am more aware of how it is a social construct, I still don’t resist conventional roles/norms per se, as I don’t know what I would be fighting for/against, but my form of resistance lies in the power imbalance, and the use of gender’s and identities derogatorily. Mainly, I “resist” any individual or idea that holds itself/themselves to a more privileged, higher level than its counterparts. Since identity is largely due to socialization, I feel that society denying an individual’s choices as to who or what they want to be/become to be foolish and hypocritical. After all, individual ideas collectively created society and nobody questioned the norms and conventions when they were being constructed, so who is to say what can or can’t be part of society or even if it is “finished.”
*I mixed up the authors by accident in the first paragraph :S
“I was/am not homophobic. I was just apathetic, which arguably could be just as worse.”
I want to know what you meant by that, and if I catch on, then to expand a bit. Uncaring about someone’s sexual preference [which is logical, as it has no affects on you], or the general mistreatment of homosexuals that has gone on for so long that it’s as normal as wearing your favorite pair of jeans? If the latter, you made a perfect example of our desensitization towards negativities we all have as a whole towards unfamiliar social digressions. We took a word [gay] and it went from positive, to negative, and then to negative again, but a sort of flippant negativity.
“Tough, not because it’s difficult to find the answer, but tough because it is difficult TO answer. I would like to say that I have not been pressured to conform in any way shape or form but deep down I know that I am largely a product of society. (What a terrible thing to admit, I guess I’m not exactly a special little snowflake :P.)”
Another great example I’d love to agree with you on. We have all also fallen into a wave of “being unique.” Everyone is different, “special,” and we all deserve recognition for it and put vast amounts subconscious effort into remaining so. However, the same logic that could be applied to anyone else’s conformity could be just as rational on the one of everyone being unique. If we all are, no one is. And no one really is. We all fit into some sort of “YEAH IM A REBEL, COOL AND EDGY” category. There’s only so many combinations a set of characteristics can make before we’re all similar to someone, if not multiple people, somewhere. Especially when it comes to our gender. As much of a butterfly all the little rebels would like to feel they are, we all blend in to an extreme extent in one way or another. Fighting gender norms would just be another movement. However, the difference is how we revolt against all the negative ones to be a better unit of human beings.
I agree with you when you said you always thought that gender was inherit/genetic. I didn’t learn until recently that this was untrue, just how the “maternal instinct” is not real either. Just because you are pregnant doesn’t mean that you know how to be a mother. You learn how to be a mother. You also learn to create your own opinions on gender, and you learn by socializing how to be a boy or girl. Several girls identify themselves as tom boys and are proud of it. Boys being like girls are “sissy like.”
About you saying that we are having to conform to a society “norm” is kind of true. As much as you dislike it I dislike it too. People want to feel special or unique but even the people who try the hardest to be unique are just copying someone else or something that they have seen. When you were talking about different cultures it was interesting because not everyone gets to experience that. I’m taking a communications class where we are talking about gender and non verbal communication, and it’s amazing what is acceptable in our society is not in others. We are a very loose laid back life style compared to other countries but at the same time we are uptight over issues like gender where religion rules our society in that area.
Apparently I've written too much for blogger to handle, so I'll be leaving you several small comments =P
“I personally believe that I am still an amateur at best in issues and topics related to gender but I am under the impression that "gender," as an institution, is/was constructed by society. Assuming that this as absolute truth, is it not true that one ultimately has the option, despite social resistance, to decide their gender?”
Of course everyone has the choice of whether or not they conform to their “gender.” But, how can one fight it as a child if it’s being taught on levels of morality, and an ignorant mind cannot comprehend beyond it, despite the discomforts it brings them? Like a struggle with your non/religious virtues as a child. It feels normal depending on how you‘re raised. We may choose what we want, but you cannot fight something you’re being taught is right when you’re young. Gender decision is up to personal choice when the mind is capable of choosing so. Whether consciously or subconsciously. Which is why I believe nothing but what is proper for a human to develop healthy and emotionally sound should be pushed until they are capable of swinging one way or the other [or not swinging at all].
“Putting that aside, what I'm trying to figure out is where you place yourself in this gender spectrum. It doesn't matter to me really where you are, I would just like to put things into perspective.”
I’ve not chosen a gender. I dress in comfortable clothing, despite it’s masculinity or femininity, unless it is to humour my dear mother [then the “girly” side comes out and I get to shift uncomfortably ass day in a skirt or dress as I fight to keep my knees together]. I do not consider myself too emotional [as is deemed a female trait], nor too apathetic and analytical [male]. I believe my sense of empathy [that’s almost so potent it’s smothering] is normal to human beings, not a sex. I don’t believe my calloused objectivity while tackling personal problems makes me more of a man, it also makes me human. In short, I am a human. I have the sex of a female, and I’d like to believe I’m a balance between expectancies of both “genders.”
This was an uncanny reoccurrence, and I’ve grown weary of it. This has lead to a strong distaste for my current gender age group. I’ve never been rude or cruel to my gender, and in return I’ve suffered constant mistreatment because I didn’t mesh well with them. Hold me at fault as much as you may, but as you can imagine this has lead to a strong distaste for my current gender age group.
Oh man. I sound like such a cry baby.
“I have to admit, I tried to look up who you were in the class and since I am not familiar with the majority of the class yet, I think it was for the better. It somehow makes this response more objective. I like it.”
I could tell you if you like, but something about anonymity makes my toes curl with delight.
And on a final unrelated note: You thoroughly flatter me with your comments on the way I write. It's a craft I've spent many years working hard to perfect, so my deepest thanks and gratitude go out to you.
And sorry if my thoughts grew disjointed and scrambled at any point.
and sorry if I sound angry/ or like I'm attacking you. It's not my intent. I just tend to mince words and be a bit blunt with the choice of my language.
I liked how you said that you got yelled at for saying "my computer was being gay." I used to say phrases like that all the time until I realized that it can sometimes really hurt someones feelings. I am Filipino as well and seeing two men kiss or hold hands was maybe a little weird to me when I was younger, but growing up and developing my own sense of ideas on things, it did not weird me out at all. I do know that in the Philippines, homosexuality is accepted which I think is amazing! I really wish that the US could be a little more accepting as well.
"I feel that society denying an individual’s choices as to who or what they want to be/become to be foolish and hypocritical." I loved how you said this because it is very true. I think it is very wrong to deny someone to be who they want to be. It's so sad that our society does this and judges people so heavily. Just like you said though, before you can really determine what kind of person you are and what you believe in, everyone's a "generalized other" and it isn't until you find out who you really are that everyone else becomes your significant other.